The White Slave Trade Hysteria

 

I found it surprising that I had never heard of the white slave trade hysteria until this class. I thought that Traffic in Souls was a great foundation setter because it gave me a perspective on what life was like in the early 1900s. It set the scene for the low-quality films, the lack of dialogue, and reminded me of how little technology had progressed at this point.

I found it saddening to think about the women who were genuinely fearful for their lives during this time period. Since that time period, I think society has come a long way for women to have less fear about being alone out in public, though it is still prevalent within larger cities. I believe a lot of this fear is psychological because of preconceived notions that the white slave trade and other fear movements have set in place. This summer, I lived in New York City, and on occasion would walk home from work late at night by myself. I never had any issues, though I likely would have felt more comfortable if I were not a 21-year-old female. However, 100 years ago, a girl would never have felt safe enough to walk home at night, and it is my hope that society continues taking steps toward eliminating women’s feelings of a lack of safety on their own.

In class, we recently talked about the Salem Witch Trials, and the white slave trade reminded me of how hysteria, time and time again, has fueled movements with little to no evidence. One similar instance that comes to mind regarding modern times is the 2008 bank failures. Upon first thought, the 2008 panic may seem different from the white slave trade, though both were a result of human perception and panic. Bank runs are caused by consumer fear, worsening the crisis, and occasionally have little support. The white slave trade hysteria, similarly, had little support and was amplified by films, politicians, and the rapid spread of fear.  Additionally, both panics were influential enough to require new reforms: The Mann Act and Dodd-Frank.

All in all, I enjoyed learning about this time in history that I previously knew little about.

 

Comments

  1. williams.dan76October 7, 2025 at 6:59 AM

    Tanks, Anslee, I appreciate your thoughts and insights. I especially liked your analogy between the White Slave Panic of 1910 and the 2008 bank panic. I had not thought about this, but you are correct--both panics were fueled by hysteria without much substance. Banks are only as good as the confidence people have in them. Panics occur when people lose that confidence and run to banks to pull their money out. Both hysterias were fueled by rampant fear. Women certainly have come a long way, and I hope the progress towards equality and acceptance continues. Because my daughter's name often appears on the covers of DC comic books, she gets hate mail from Incel boys.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Scams and Phishing Reflection

  When first analyzing videos and historical accounts of alleged phishing attempts, I was surprised by the gullibility of individuals, yet also disappointed in the lack of education around these topics. Upon a deeper dive, I realized the true sophistication of certain scams and how they play on individuals emotions. For example, targeting and taking advantage of a lonely uneducated windowed woman with plenty of free time on her hands rather than going after a busy educated individual. Additionally, I was surprised by the statistics - such as the fact that phishing losses exceeded $10.3 billion in 2022. The idea that a massive amount of money is associated with deception is saddening and shocking, and, surprisingly, it is not discussed more. In my personal life, I experience scam attempts on a weekly basis. Whether that be a Texas Toll Tag fraud master persuading me to pay a bill, or an individual impersonating my boss and requesting my personal information. Through online training ...
Read more

Hoaxes

  In class, we discussed hoaxes and the many reasons of motivation behind them. Our discussion reminded me of a recent time when I hoaxed a friend, Rocco, for fun. When recently in Las Vegas, my friends hired a bodyguard, Mark, to come to different events with us. Rocco befriended Mark, who inspired him to sign up for jiu-jitsu classes. After returning to Texas, in good fun, my friend Anna Clay created a fake burner phone number and sent a text to Rocco pretending to be Mark. Rocco, being gullible, fell for the hoax and was sad when he found out his new friend Mark actually wasn’t checking in on the jiu-jitsu training. With this recent experience, it reminded me that hoaxes sometimes are easier to fall for when they cause the hoaxee to believe something they already wanted to believe. This shows confirmation bias and makes people more likely to fall into the trap. I enjoyed our discussion of hoaxes and found it to be transferable across multiple historical events, from the Cardif...
Read more

Millerite Movement

  I found interesting in the Millerite Movement how so many people collectively went against what the Bible says. The Bible says we do not know the time of the rapture, so to not go looking for it. However, people were so anxious for the coming of the Messiah that they jumped the gun and went looking anyways. Additionally, I think it is interesting how these predictions still happen today. Several churches I have visited throughout my faith journey have shared thoughts of “the rapture coming during our time.” Part of me sees this as a marketing ploy – to keep members returning to church so they will be sanctified when the rapture does occur. However, I want to give them the benefit of the doubt and believe that church leaders genuinely believe in what they are preaching. I was also shocked by the Millerite Movement’s ability to retain followers after failed predictions. I think people continued to follow the movement because people like to have something to believe in. The movem...
Read more